Eugene City Councilor Ward 8

Apparent hostage situation at UO ends in arrest

05 November 2021

 Randy Groves

A comment from Councilor Groves: Another dangerous situation highlighting the mental health crisis we and many communities are facing. All too often mental health problems default to our police officers and firefighters as the last line of defense because we have failed to address the problem earlier in the process. We the public are then dissatisfied with the outcome and blame our responders when it is the system we created that has failed. 

Health and human services, which includes mental health, is a function of county and state government in Oregon, but like our unhoused problem, it is something that effects everyone, and all levels of our government need to work effectively with one another to address this situation. Likewise, our non-profit organizations must work seamlessly and effectively if we hope to bring this problem under control.

I know that many of you here locally are thinking, what about CAHOOTS? In fact, I hear many people - with no street level response experience - describe CAHOOTS as the panacea to all of our problems. I agree that CAHOOTS is an important component of our response system and ideally positioned to respond to a band of non-violent or the most basic of medical incidents, but CAHOOTS like police and fire, needs a place to take many of the people they encounter. Otherwise it is like having a good ambulance system but no hospital, or a police force with no jail or alternative facility to provide help. Our mental health system needs a back end to effectively address this problem.

Apparent hostage situation at UO ends in arrest

Louis Krauss

Eugene Register-Guard USA TODAY NETWORK

A 37-year-old armed man was taken into custody Thursday morning on the University of Oregon campus after he allegedly held two students hostage in Hamilton Hall and set off a fire alarm in the UO Knight Law Center.

The man was taken into custody without incident after the hostages were able to text his location in the dorm to police. He was armed with a loaded 9 mm pistol and had extra ammunition, UO Police Chief Matt Carmichael said. He was arrested and charged with menacing, burglary, criminal trespass, kidnapping and carrying a concealed firearm. He is being held inLane County Jail. The incident started around 3 a.m. Thursday when a fire alarm was pulled in the UO Knight Law Center. After finding no evidence of fire, University of Oregon police checked security camera footage and saw a person pull the alarm while holding a gun and “acting erratically,” Carmichael said at 2:30 p.m. Thursday news conference.

Lane County Sheriff’s Office, UO, Springfield and Junction City police responded, locking down and evacuating the building.

A search of the building was conducted by a Sheriff’s Office drone team and a Springfield police canine unit before an alert was sent out at 6:30 a.m. to the UO community asking everyone to avoid the area, Carmichael said. “A little after the initial fire alarm, we received some odd 911 calls,” Carmichael said. The 911 calls came from the same cellphone reporting incidents from different areas of campus. UO police found that the phone belonged to a student in the Hamilton dorm, and that student and one other were being held in their dorm room against their will by the suspect, Carmichael said.

“We quickly determined this individual had left Knight Law School and had gone to Hamilton dorm, where he detained a student and a guest in their dorm room for a couple of hours,” he said at a press conference.

After the suspect left the room, the texting from the student helped lead police to the suspect, Carmichael said. The suspect had been using the student’s phone to place 911 calls, the chief said.

Concern over vague campus-wide alert

A campus-wide alert was sent out a little after 6:30 a.m., several hours after the incident began, with minimal information other than “law enforcement activity is occurring near Knight Law” and to avoid the area. An “all clear” alert was sent out at 8:05 a.m. Audrey Kalman, a 21year-old senior at UO, said she was upset the school didn’t provide more detail informing students there was an armed suspect detaining people in their room. “I can’t imagine the experience of those students, but even if I were in that dorm, I’d be like, why the hell weren’t we told this?” Kalman said. “Especially on a college campus where people are out all hours of the night. I just think it should have been communicated to the students at the time instead of this vague ‘law enforcement’ thing.” She said it felt like the school was downplaying the incident, and said in the past alerts have specified what the danger is more. On Oct. 30, for instance, a UO alert warned the community of an armed suspect and gave his description.Carmichael said the timing of the alert was around when people were beginning to come back onto campus, and that it was at a time when significant police presence had the area well-contained.

“The timeliness was consistent with one, be- ing safe, and then second making sure people are aware there was a pretty large police presence and we’re looking for this individual,” he said.

Classes not in Knight Law went as normal

Students reported Agate Street being blocked off by police cars Thursday morning. One custodian said police were seen going into the law building with guns drawn and dogs. Witnesses also reported not seeing many people evacuating due tohow early it was. The front desk staff in the law school building declined to comment on the incident, and the front doors were unlocked at around 8:40 a.m.A little after 7 a.m. Marcilynn Burke, dean of the UO School of Law, told the law school community in an email to avoid the building and to avoid it even after the allout. “In light of the situation at the law school, all classes, meetings, and activities should be moved online (ZOOM) this morning,” Burke added. “If you cannot do so, please plan to reschedule those activities.” Other classes not in the Knight Law building were still held as normal. Carmichael noted there would be additional police presence on campus Thursday night to make community members feel more safe.

Louis Krauss covers breaking news for The Register-Guard. Contact him at lkrauss@register guard.com, and follow him on Twitter @LouisKclear message was sent raussNews.

University of Oregon Police Chief Matthew Carmichael talks to the media about an armed suspect accused of holding students captive in a dorm room.


Copyright © 2021 The Register-Guard 11/5/2021

Randy Groves